← Quora archive  ·  2013 Mar 29, 2013 10:40 PM PDT

Question

According to you, what was the underlying message from Foundation by Isaac Asimov?

Answer

I don't think there is one. Asimov doesn't come across as a very ideological writer. His nonfiction reveals a rather conventional, almost banal mid-century kind of unexamined American moral scientism. His popular introductions to science and the bible are particularly revealing. I found them hugely interesting and useful as a high school kid precisely because they had no subtle postmodern cleverness. Just good, basic exposition that competently introduced me to a baseline common sense take on many things.

Asimov thought a lot, about a lot of things, and very intelligently, but not particularly deeply or with much philosophical nuance. His thinking is -- and this is going to sound snobbish, but is actually a compliment -- robust and workmanlike rather than overwrought. I suspect he would have had little patience with modern writers who have a tendency to be too subtle.

Fortunately, he was also an ambitious, energetic (takes a lot of schlepping to build such a huge story) and inventive storyteller with a great sense of humor (Clarke lacked that). Almost like J. K. Rowling in a way, but with more skill and better command over character development. But still not much more than two dimensional. Message-heavy fiction tends to be character-driven, and Asimov is very plot-driven.

So Foundation is mainly a big, sprawling popcorn space opera. Things that seem like they might be message-laden, like the 4 laws, or the 1st/2nd foundation duality, turn out to be either shallow plot devices or not really explored deeply.

In other words, sit back and enjoy the ride. It's a kind of fun that writers rarely seem to have with their work anymore, so enjoy it for the escapist entertainment it is. Leave your message-hunting for Clarke's books, Dune, LOTR etc.